FAQ City: Why Do CMS High Schools Start So Early?

Sep 10, 2019

Waking up is hard. Even harder when you're a teenager who has to be at the bus stop at 6 a.m.

One WFAE listener, Jennifer Morell, wrote in to "FAQ City" wondering why our high schools start so early in the morning, and if our kids might be better served if we pushed back the opening bell.

As it turns out, Charlotte-Mecklenburg Schools did consider delaying high school start times several years ago, but the school board ultimately decided against it.

The proposal was made by a CMS task force composed of several parents and education professionals. They argued the early start times interfered with students' sleep, and that CMS could improve students' academic performance and mental well-being by simply opening schools later.

That was backed up by research from the American Academy of Pediatrics, which found teenagers are biologically wired to stay up later than adults and young children. Most of them can't fall asleep before 11 p.m., the researchers found, and forcing them to get up early only leads to chronic sleep deprivation.

The academy recommended middle and high schools start no earlier than 8:30 a.m., and by shifting to a later start, schools could potentially see higher test scores and graduation rates, reduce car crashes caused by sleepy teenagers, and fight against obesity and sport injuries.

Susan Plaza, a parent and former CMS teacher herself, was among those on the task force. She tells us the proposal had support from then-Superintendent Heath Morrison, but the plan was scuttled amid Morrison's abrupt firing in October 2014.

The plan also faced opposition from some CMS administrators and members of the school board who worried the change would disrupt the everyday routines of CMS families and could interfere with after-school sports or students' jobs, not to mention the added cost of new buses.

On this episode of the "FAQ City" podcast, we'll speak with Susan Plaza and revisit the proposal that never came to pass. We'll also ask if it could resurface now that a new CMS superintendent is in place.

Do you have a question about Charlotte's people, culture or history? Let us know! Submit your question in the box below, and we may be in touch.

While you're at it, make sure to subscribe and rate/review the podcast on Apple PodcastsNPR One, and Google Play.

_