© 2020 WFAE
90.7 Charlotte 93.7 Southern Pines 90.3 Hickory 106.1 Laurinburg
Play Live Radio
Next Up:
Available On Air Stations
The Party Line is dedicated to examining regional issues and policies through the figures who give shape to them. These are critical, complex, and even downright confusing times we live in. There’s a lot to navigate nationally and in the Carolinas; whether it’s elections, debates on gay marriage, public school closings, or tax incentives for economic development. The Party Line’s goal is to offer a provocative, intelligent look at the issues and players behind the action; a view that ultimately offers the necessary insight for Carolina voters to hold public servants more accountable.

Democrats Have Upper Hand In Electoral College Strategy


Our political history has seen rare instances where the nation, as a whole, has been consistent in terms of “red” versus “blue” states in our presidential elections.  Yet, since 2000, the fact that regionalism serves as a guiding force in our electoral maps has made the past four presidential elections notable.

Since the 1990s, the country has settled into what Merle and Earle Black, twin brothers who happen to teach political science, describe as base regions, with one region serving as the battleground for the country.

In their book “Divided America,” the Black brothers note that the Democrats and Republicans can call on two regions across the country for their bases. The Democrats have been the party of the Northeast and Pacific coast, while the GOP has been anchored in the South through the desert Southwest and turning up the spine of the Rocky Mountains.

The Midwest has been the true battleground section of the country.  And we see that pattern in the 2000 and 2004 presidential election map. 

2000 US Election.jpg
2004 US Election.jpg

The 2004 map confirmed what the Black brothers have argued and shows the distinctive pattern, with the GOP having 234 to the Democrat’s 189 base electoral votes.  With the magic number of 270 electoral votes needed, the Republicans appeared to have the distinct advantage in the Electoral College. Democrats needed to sweep the Midwest or “crack” the GOP regions to have a fighting chance.

The other remarkable aspect of going from 2000 to 2004 was the consistency of 47 states in their voting patterns. Only three states “flipping” from one election to the other (New Hampshire, Iowa, and New Mexico). 

Coming out of the 2004 loss, the Obama campaign recognized the need to “expand the electorate.” And not only did they do so in the battleground region, they expanded the battle in the GOP’s backyards, especially with the help of critical minority voting blocs.

In 2008, Obama’s campaign added over 10 million votes nationwide to what John Kerry received in 2008, and in the two critical GOP base regions, his campaign added 1.8 million votes in three Southern states (VA, NC, and FL) and over 500,000 votes in three Southwest/Mountain states (NV, NM, and CO) to flip them into the Democratic win column. 

2008 US Election.jpg

In three battleground Midwest states, Obama’s campaign added 690,000 votes to Kerry’s performance in Iowa, Ohio, and Indiana, thereby flipping those states to Democrats. 

By peeling off six states in the South and Southwest and having a competitive advantage in the Midwest, Obama’s chances of replicating the 2008 strategy in his re-election bid hung on whether a turnout operation could again crack several states from the GOP base.

2012 Presidential Election.jpg

In this year’s election, we see the same pattern emerge again like we did in 2008, with only Indiana and North Carolina flipping.  Obama saw his vote margins drop from four years ago in all but two of the “flipped” states (Indiana and North Carolina).

And while Romney was able to gain votes in seven of the nine 2008 flipped states, it was not enough to overcome the margin of victory that Obama had built up, even with fewer Democratic votes. 

Ultimately, the 2012 electorate shrunk in size, going from 131 million to approximately 122 million: the bulk of the votes (nearly 7.3 million) came out of Obama’s 2008 numbers, while Romney lost 1.1 million from what McCain did in 2008.

The lesson, however, is for the GOP to learn that if the party can’t solidify its two base regions of the South and Southwest/Mountains, especially with big electoral votes out of Virginia and Florida, it will be harder and harder to put together that magic number of 270 votes.

And the likelihood of other states being cracked, such as Arizona and Texas (the second largest electoral state) should be of concern to the national Republican Party going into the future.

We Need Your Help Now More Than Ever

WFAE mask

Our newsroom is hard at work covering everything from the ongoing coronavirus pandemic to the aftermath of the election, the race for a vaccine and our communities' fight to rebuild. But we can't do it without you. Support our local journalism with a donation of ANY amount, and we’ll send you a free WFAE member mask courtesy of AllDayMask.com of Monroe.