Asheville's Mission Health fined by the state for not reporting an employee’s COVID death
Mission Health in Asheville has been fined almost $30,000 by the North Carolina Department of Labor for violating health and safety laws. The eight violations include not reporting a work-related COVID-19 hospitalization or the employee’s subsequent death in November 2021.
HCA Healthcare and Copestone, a mental health service that is part of Mission Health, were both cited for failing to ensure that respirator masks, such as N-95 masks, were fit-tested or tracking fit-testing in October 2021. The N-95 respirator masks are worn by staff when working with COVID-positive patients.
National Nurses Organizing Committee, which represents 1,500 nurses at Mission Health, applauded the action.
“We union nurses have been fighting for a safer workplace throughout the pandemic,” said Kerri Wilson, an RN in the cardiac step-down unit at Mission Hospital, said in a news release.
“Our workplace is safer because we spoke up, we reported safety violations, and we took the time to show OSH investigators what needed to be corrected," Wilson said. "Because our union contract protects our ability to advocate, we know that we can play an active role in exposing the shortcomings of management.”
HCA, which owns Mission Health, was given 15 working days starting March 22 to respond to the citations by requesting a conference or an appeal. The other option is to pay the penalties.
Mission Health spokesperson Nancy Lindell said that Mission is looking into the citations.
"The safety and well-being of our patients and caregivers is our top priority," said Lindell in an email. "We know the importance in fit-testing and only paused the practice at the guidance of the North Carolina Department of Labor and OSHA early in the pandemic. Once it was deemed appropriate to reinstate the practice in 2021, Mission Hospital took steps to do so. We value the OSHA tracking and reporting process, however, we are working with them to clarify these recent findings."
When asked about the COVID-related employee death at Mission, Lindell said that there was no evidence that the death was work-related.
"We are deeply saddened by the loss of one of our caregivers," Lindell said in an email. "We have no evidence that directly ties their illness to the loving care they gave our patients."
The state Labor Department says that it cannot comment on Mission’s specific case because it is still in the 15-day open inspection. However, the department clarified that a workplace fatality is one that can clearly be tied to the workplace.
“Basically, if there’s a reasonable belief that the employee contracted COVID at the worksite and the person subsequently died of COVID, the employer should report the fatality to the OSH Division,” said Jennifer Haigwood, director of communications and policy development at the department, said in an email.
The department also shared an April 2020 memo that outlined temporary enforcement guidance during the COVID-19 pandemic. The memo explained that as long as employers were attempting to comply with OSHA standards, due to difficulties related to the pandemic, employers would be given “good-faith discretion.”
The memo states: “Discretionary enforcement of OSHA standards by the OSH Division, and in accordance with the attached OSHA memorandum is contingent upon evidence that the employer has made good-faith efforts to comply with annual and other recurring requirements of an OSHA standard and has a contingency plan in place to fulfill these requirements when business and availability of services have resumed.”
Here’s the full breakdown of the citations:
- In response to an October 2021 inspection, the Department of Labor issued a citation to Mission Health because the employer allegedly did not ensure that the employees using a tight-fitting facepiece respirator were fit-tested prior to wearing the respirators; and then fit-tested annually afterward. Mission also didn’t keep track of the fit tests administered. These were serious and non-serious violations totaling a proposed penalty of $7,275.
- In response to a November 2021 inspection, theC Department of Labor issued a citation to Mission Health for the same fit test issues. This time the penalty increased to $7,000 and $975, respectively. Mission Health is also cited for not reporting the COVID-19 work-related hospitalization and subsequent death of an employee on Nov. 10, 2021. These are both non-serious violations with a proposed penalty of $5,000 and $2,250, respectively; with the fit-test citations, the penalties total $15,225.
- In response to an October 2021 inspection at Copestone, theC Department of Labor issued a citation to Mission Health because the employer allegedly did not ensure that the employees using a tight-fitting facepiece respirator were fit-tested prior to wearing the respirators and then fit-tested annually afterward. Mission also didn’t keep track the fit tests administered. These were serious and non-serious violations totaling a proposed penalty of $7,275.
Total proposed penalties equal $29,775.
This story has been updated with Mission's response.