© 2021 WFAE
90.7 Charlotte 93.7 Southern Pines 90.3 Hickory 106.1 Laurinburg
Play Live Radio
Next Up:
Available On Air Stations
Welcome to WFAEats - a fun adventure where we explore all things tasty and interesting in the Charlotte food scene. We want to share stories, recipes and culinary escapades and hear about yours!

Oyster Stuffing, Friends A Must For Thanksgiving Swap


Those who dread a lonesome holiday, listen up.

It’s possible to find a friend and trade hosting. Nov. 22 marks the 26th time we’ve swapped hosting.

It can work. Trust me on this.

Our swap began when a friend, Nancy invited us for Thanksgiving turkey in 1986. She and her husband didn’t have family close by either. At the time there were four adults and two toddlers around the table and their dog, Molly, beneath it. Life was complicated in its own way, and packing up our son’s toddler gear, we absently drove off with the leftovers on top of our car. Some lucky scavenger enjoyed our turkey leg along the highway.

The next year, we hosted. Our first “mystery guest” arrived in the form of Nancy’s friend Michelle, guard at a female prison, who wouldn’t have had a home-cooked meal if it hadn’t been for our turkey and cranberries and my famous oyster stuffing.

We liked the idea of extra guests, and over the years we’ve entertained several—a pair of newlyweds, the neighbor boys, a divorcee, a family in the process of moving, a nanny from Australia.

A big advantage to host-swapping is that you only have to clean your house every other year. The other is that your dining room table is full and others share the cooking, but it hasn’t been all fun and frivolity. In 1990, our mystery guests refused my oyster stuffing (their loss).

In 1995, an expensive water goblet shattered. In 1997, we postponed for illness. In 2002, I received the call after dinner that my mother died. Three days later, Nancy’s mother died. Thanksgiving, like life isn’t always joyous.

The holiday exchange started simply. Our friends didn’t have family nearby and neither did we, so why not share? There’s no reason why a similar swap won’t work for any holiday. The trick is to find amiable folks who are willing to share.

Our kids have grown up without memories of a “family” Thanksgiving, but they have no concept of the family bickering that can accompany such gatherings. As they say, you can pick your friends, not your family.

On Thanksgiving 2011 we were back to the original four adults (we’re still married to the same spouses) and Nancy’s youngest daughter. The first two toddlers have since grown and moved away. In this lull before grandkids, we’re doing okay and the turkey leg will make it home.

Through 26 years of change we’ve enjoyed three constants: roast turkey, cranberries and oyster stuffing—comfort food for misshapen lives. All three have shouted Thanksgiving to me since I was a child, though the oyster part sounds terribly New England for a family in the Cornbelt.

About the stuffing: my mother proffered advice from her mother: Don’t use selects, the standards are pricey enough.

In 2003 my oyster stuffing recipe appeared in Amy Rogers’ cookbook, Hungry for Home: Stories of Food from Across the Carolinas.

Credit SisterMaryEris
Oyster Stuffing

Here’s the recipe:

  • 2 sticks margarine
  • 1 onion, chopped
  • ½ c. celery, chopped
  • 2 bags herbed bread stuffing
  • 2 ½ cups water
  • 2 cans fresh oysters, undrained
  • sage to taste

Preheat oven to 350 degrees. Grease 2-quart baking dish. Saute’ onion and celery in margarine; then in large bowl, combine with the bread crumbs and water. Mix in oysters and sage. Add enough water to moisten the crumbs well. Bake in greased dish about an hour or until top is well browned.
Yield 12 to 16 servings.