North Carolina University Leaders Depart Amid Culture War
When Carol Folt gave her first big speech as head of North Carolina's flagship public university, she praised lawyer Julius Chambers, who battled segregationists in court, and she lauded legendary basketball coach Dean Smith's civil rights advocacy. The Tar Heel titans "worked across differences for the common good," she said in 2013.
But Folt was pushed out this week amid an ongoing culture war about what, exactly, is the common good.
The chancellor of the University of North Carolina's Chapel Hill campus had called out heavy equipment early Tuesday morning to remove the marble base of a Confederate statue that was ripped down in August. Her unilateral action makes it harder to restore the campus memorial to UNC students who fought for the slave-holding states.
Folt said she acted to protect public safety because the pedestal remained a focal point of passionate protests, both pro and con. The statue nicknamed "Silent Sam" had stood on a prominent plaza named for a slave-owning educator since 1913, when it was dedicated with a white-supremacist speech by a former Confederate.
Also pushed out was President George W. Bush's education secretary Margaret Spellings, who resigned in October as president of the state's universities.
The episodes are fresh evidence that more than 150 years after it ended, the Civil War remains a cultural fault line for many Southerners.
But the ousters also represent the revenge of conservative Trump voters against university academics who seem culturally alien, said Jay Schalin, policy analysis director at the James G. Martin Center for Academic Renewal, a Raleigh-based conservative think tank. Their representatives, who dominate the state's legislature and university system's board, told Folt and Spellings to leave weeks earlier than they planned to go.
"We are essentially seeing the national culture war being played out in a local arena," Schalin said Thursday. "We are seeing a new dynamic in America, in that many of the people who have not had a voice are now getting a voice. And it's being played out in the UNC system and on the UNC-Chapel Hill campus."
Similar skirmishes have taken place at public universities in Nebraska, Iowa, California and Alabama in recent years, but they go back decades — at least since the blowback against teaching evolution and long before 1960s campus radicalism.
Most Americans think the country's higher education system is headed in the wrong direction, a Pew Research Center survey last summer found. About three-quarters of Republicans objected to professors bringing their political and social views into the classroom. About the same proportion thought there was too much concern about protecting students from views they might find offensive.
Spellings resigned after friction with the public university Board of Governors. Board members second-guessed her choices to name chancellors who run campuses and her own safety concerns about "Silent Sam" after a violent 2017 white-rights march in Charlottesville, Virginia.
Folt's standing with the governing board was unclear before her surprise move. The former biologist who left the Ivy League's Dartmouth College for Chapel Hill had overseen a fundraising drive that raised more than $2 billion as of last summer, half of its ambitious goal. The university's research funding had grown by 13 percent to $883 million under Folt.
She received the largest raise among state campus leaders in December 2017, three months after board members criticized her not taking a hard line against post-Charlottesville demonstrators demanding "Silent Sam's" removal.
But last summer Silent Sam was ripped off its base, and Folt got no bump to her $633,000 salary three months later.
Folt's campus trustees and several big fundraisers have said this week they support her. Most professors probably felt it was best for "Silent Sam" to go, but even more agreed the issue has festered for too long and needed resolution, said North Carolina Central University law professor David Green, who heads the group representing faculty on all 17 campuses.
Schalin believes the public university governing board will continue setting a more conservative course for the system's presidents. It's time to encourage teaching broadly shared cultural values, he said.
The "culture of academia is very strongly in conflict with a great deal of the country," Schalin said. "The campuses cannot remain one-sided and expect to get funding and be treated with respect by everybody."
But demanding conservative orthodoxy would threaten the Chapel Hill school's top reputation, said Stephen Trachtenberg, president emeritus at George Washington University in Washington, D.C. The purpose of the university is to foster exploration and debate by weighing both the conservative and the revolutionary, he said.
"It's the kind of university that you'd want to work at, the kind of university you'd want your children to go to," said Trachtenberg, who has consulted on recruiting top academic positions. "But it's not the kind of university that you would go to as a leader, because the board doesn't understand that there's a job of the trustees and the job of the chancellors and the presidents."